This fish recipe was easy to make, but tasted elevated.
Lizzy Briskin
I tried Ina Garten's sheet-pan, mustard-roasted fish recipe, which calls for just six ingredients.
The dish came together quickly, and the sauce was tangy and rich.
I'll definitely make this dish again, both for easy meals and dinner parties with friends.
Whenever I'm looking for a simple dinner recipe, I pick up an Ina Garten cookbook.
The Barefoot Contessa is known for her no-fuss recipes that deliver big on flavor, and she's rarely led me astray. So, when I came across a 2008 recipe for mustard-roasted fish, cooked on a sheet pan and ready in under 30 minutes, I had to give it a try.
Now, this elegant fish dish has become my go-to for easy meals and dinner parties alike. It's just fancy enough without being complicated.
The ingredients are simple but flavorful.captiontk
Lizzy Briskin
You don't need a long list of ingredients for this fish recipe. The first, of course, is the fish, and though Garten suggests red snapper, you can use the sauce in this recipe on most varieties of fish, from salmon to tilapia.
I recommend something flaky and flat — think cod, rather than swordfish or tuna — because the flavor-packed sauce livens up milder seafood. I used Wild Alaska Sole, which is also sometimes labeled flounder.
Speaking of sauce, the fish is absolutely drenched in a rich, tangy combination of crème fraîche, two mustards (Dijon and whole-grain), shallots, and capers.
The mustard duo brings acidity and a bit of a back-of-the-throat heat to the dish, while capers add lovely brininess and shallots add some bite and texture.
Finally, crème fraîche, a high-fat cultured dairy product, is less tangy than sour cream but wonderfully rich — exactly what a lean fish fillet needs.
The dish takes under 10 minutes to prep.captiontk
Lizzy Briskin
If your fish is frozen, be sure to defrost it first.
Then, the recipe comes together in a snap. First, arrange the fillets on a baking sheet or in a baking dish. I used five fillets instead of four, as mine were thinner and smaller than the 8-ounce fillets Garten recommends.
Don't worry if they overlap; you're not looking for crispiness in this recipe, so there's little risk of overcrowding the pan.
Then, it's time to whip up the sauce. Simply stir everything together in a bowl, then cover the fish evenly. The goal is to cover the fish in sauce, but they don't need to be swimming in it (no pun intended).
I cooked the fish in under 20 minutes, then topped it off with more sauce.captiontk
Lizzy Briskin
Even if you're using thicker fish fillets than I did, delicate white fish (as well as flaky salmon and trout) takes about 10 to 12 minutes per inch of thickness to cook through at 425 degrees Fahrenheit.
Garten recommends checking for doneness after 10 minutes and pulling the fish from the oven when "it's barely done," since it will continue to cook for several minutes outside the oven.
If you want to be totally sure, seafood is considered safe to eat when it reaches an internal temperature of 145 degrees Fahrenheit. The key here, in Garten's words: "Be sure not to overcook it!"
There will be a fair amount of sauce left in the pan after cooking, but don't let it go to waste. I suggest spooning the excess sauce over the fish in the baking dish or on your serving plates.
You can serve the dish hot from the oven or at room temperature.captiontk
Lizzy Briskin
I ate the dish with a side of Broccolini, which I roasted while preparing and cooking the fish. I served it hot from the oven, but Garten says you can also serve it at room temperature.
Flavor-wise, the dish hit the right note between light and rich: The mild fish soaks up the tangy, mustardy sauce that's just salty enough, thanks to the capers.
The nice thing about covering delicate fish in a thick, rich sauce is that it prevents the seafood from drying out. For that reason, I think this recipe would also make a great addition to a hosting menu, since you can easily make it ahead of time.
I highly recommend enjoying this fish recipe with crusty bread, rice, or another starch to soak up all that flavor-packed sauce. Once you try this low-effort, high-reward recipe, I think you'll be joining me in adding it to your regular rotation.
We use cookies to run this site and, with your consent, to measure
traffic and improve our content. Necessary cookies are always on. You
can accept all cookies or choose which ones to allow.
Privacy policy.