Jennifer Sey fights Colorado law that could punish businesses for refusing transgender pronouns
XX-XY Athletics founder Jennifer Sey is suing Colorado over the Kelly Loving Act, arguing its anti-discrimination law threatens her free speech rights.
XX-XY Athletics founder Jennifer Sey is suing Colorado over the Kelly Loving Act, arguing its anti-discrimination law threatens her free speech rights.
Jennifer Sey has a message for the state of Colorado: She doesn't trust you, bro.
The founder of XX-XY Athletics, a company whose message centers on protecting women's sports, is suing her home state over a law she believes could force her business to abandon the very language on which it was built.
The potential consequences aren't insignificant. According to Hal Frampton, an attorney representing XX-XY Athletics who spoke with OutKick, violations of Colorado's anti-discrimination law can carry fines of up to $3,500 per violation, while certain advertising violations can constitute a Class 2 misdemeanor punishable by up to 120 days in jail.
Granted, Colorado hasn't taken any enforcement action against XX-XY Athletics since the law was passed in 2025. And that's a central part of the state's argument against granting the company legal protection while the lawsuit proceeds.
Sey, however, isn't reassured.
SUPREME COURT MAKES RULING ON TRANS ATHLETES IN WOMEN'S SPORTS
"Then why do you have the law? I mean, I don't trust you," Sey told OutKick. "That's ridiculous. That's an absurd answer."
She described the state's argument as a "trust me, bro, defense," adding: "I'm sorry, I don't trust you."
At issue is the Kelly Loving Act (HB 25-1312), a 2025 law expanding Colorado's anti-discrimination protections to include a person's chosen name and how that person chooses to be addressed — language Sey and her attorneys argue could require businesses to use pronouns and honorifics that conflict with their beliefs.
Following arguments Monday before the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Sey's attorneys are hoping to secure protection before anyone files a complaint.
"The Supreme Court has been clear time and again that Americans don't have to wait to be prosecuted to challenge unconstitutional laws," Frampton, senior counsel with Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), told OutKick.
XX-XY Athletics isn't exactly shy about its position on biological sex.
ACTIVISTS UNLEASH A 'NEXT WAVE' BALLOT STRATEGY FOR WOMEN'S SPORTS INSIDE DEEP BLUE STATES
Sey, a former national gymnastics champion and Levi's executive, launched the athletic apparel company in 2024 with the stated mission of protecting women's sports. Its advertising and social media posts regularly challenge the participation of biological males in female athletic competitions.
Earlier this month, Sey helped lead a successful campaign for Proposition 134, which Colorado voters approved with roughly 52% support. The measure requires K-12 and collegiate sports teams to be designated male, female or coed, with eligibility generally determined by biological sex. It takes effect Jan. 1.
Sey said the campaign was an uphill battle involving more than 3,000 grassroots volunteers and little funding compared with the opposition, which she said spent nearly $4.5 million.
But even after that victory, she believes Colorado's anti-discrimination law threatens her ability to discuss the issue.
"Given the speech restrictions, how can we even talk about the law itself?" Sey asked. "So these two things are in deep conflict, clearly, and we need to resolve that."
The lawsuit identifies the company's practice of referring to transgender-identifying male athletes by their biological sex. One social media post cited in court proceedings concerned a male athlete competing in girls' high-school track in Pennsylvania. Its message included the words: "When boys run girls' track, they win. And girls lose."
Sey's attorneys argue that Colorado's expanded definition of gender expression could make such statements grounds for a discrimination complaint.
"Simply sitting around and hoping that no one ever files a complaint against them is not a good strategy," Frampton said.
For Sey, the problem goes beyond the possibility of fines or legal proceedings. She believes requiring businesses to use language they reject would make it harder to challenge the very policies her company was created to oppose.
"If we call them girls, then the issue disappears," she said, referring to biological males competing in girls' sports.
In March, a federal judge denied XX-XY Athletics' request for a preliminary injunction, concluding that the company hadn't demonstrated a sufficiently credible threat of enforcement.
The ruling didn't determine whether Colorado's law violates the First Amendment. It meant the company hadn't established grounds for immediate protection while its lawsuit proceeds.
Colorado maintains that the company is exaggerating the threat.
During Monday's hearing, Janna Fischer, an attorney representing the state, accused XX-XY and other plaintiffs of seeking "the extraordinary relief of a broad preliminary injunction allowing them to misgender and deadname anyone with impunity," according to a report by Shaina Cole of Rocky Mountain Voice.
Fischer argued that the 2025 legislation "did not change any substantive rights under CADA. (Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act)" She maintained that the state's Civil Rights Division looks for a denial of service or conduct rising to the level of harassment, rather than misgendering or deadnaming alone.
Sey sees the dispute differently.
"This isn't just about me and my business. This is about all businesses. This is about all individuals," she said. "If this law exists, everybody's afraid to speak the truth."
The legal battle comes against a backdrop of Colorado's previous clashes with the U.S. Supreme Court over free speech.
In 2018, the justices ruled in favor of Colorado baker Jack Phillips in Masterpiece Cakeshop, finding that state officials had demonstrated hostility toward his religious beliefs. Five years later, in 303 Creative, the court ruled that Colorado couldn't compel a website designer to create expressive content conveying a message she opposed.
Earlier this year, in Chiles v. Salazar, the justices sided with a Colorado counselor challenging restrictions on certain conversations with clients.
Frampton pointed to all three cases in comments reported Monday by Rocky Mountain Voice.
THE CRAIG CARTON SHOW–UNFILTERED, UNAPOLOGETIC AND UNMISSABLE. DOWNLOAD HIS DAILY PODCAST NOW!
"When will they learn?" he asked, according to the outlet.
Meanwhile, Colorado's governor-elect, Phil Weiser, has already suggested that Proposition 134 could face changes. Because the measure is a statute rather than a constitutional amendment, state lawmakers can modify it.
"We're going to have to take a look at these anti-trans measures and what adjustments are necessary and appropriate," Weiser said at a post-election news conference.
Sey, who spent two years helping get Proposition 134 passed, isn't particularly receptive to that idea.
"I sort of dare him to overturn the will of the people on his first month in office," she said. "That's not going to be a good look for him, and I'll make sure everybody knows it."
This story was first published by Fox News - Latest. Read the original report
We use cookies to run this site and, with your consent, to measure traffic and improve our content. Necessary cookies are always on. You can accept all cookies or choose which ones to allow. Privacy policy.