New organ donation rules take effect after alarming reports of patients showing ‘signs of life’
New HRSA organ donation rules take effect Nov. 18, adding a five-minute waiting period after circulatory death and a formal pause process for families.
New HRSA organ donation rules take effect Nov. 18, adding a five-minute waiting period after circulatory death and a formal pause process for families.
New organ donation guidelines have taken effect as of Nov. 18, updating procedures for some donors.
The Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA), a branch of the the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), previously announced the policy update in a press release after the changes were approved by the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network in August.
The new guidelines apply to donation after circulatory death (DCD), in which organs are recovered after the heart and lungs stop functioning. This differs from donation after brain death, when the donor is declared dead based on the irreversible loss of brain function.
BRIDE IS WALKED DOWN WEDDING AISLE BY MAN WHO RECEIVED HER LATE FATHER'S HEART
The changes include a formal process to pause donation if patient safety concerns arise. Families, medical providers and other people involved in the process must be told they can request a pause and how to do so.
Procedures will also be added for handling and reporting unplanned pauses, along with more detailed records of neurological assessments.
Additionally, a minimum five-minute waiting period will be put in place after circulation stops and before organ recovery begins.
While the changes are intended to strengthen patient safeguards and improve communication with families, University of Rochester bioethicist Dr. Lainie Ross told NPR that allowing organ procurement teams to approach families before they decide whether to withdraw life-sustaining care could leave them feeling pressured or distrustful of doctors’ motives.
In public comments, the American Society of Transplantation said it supports honoring requests to pause the donation process at any point.
ORGAN HARVESTING BEGAN WHILE PATIENTS STILL SHOWED 'SIGNS OF LIFE,' FEDERAL INVESTIGATION FINDS
Previous cases in which organ recovery was reportedly begun before confirmation of death have raised questions about safeguards in the donation process. HRSA Division of Transplantation Director Dr. Raymond Lynch told Fox News Digital that "does not happen" under the process governed by the new guidelines.
"The point of these policies that were put into place is to make sure that we do preserve the sanctity of that decision and make sure that the technical parts of the operation ... pose no risk to the patient," Lynch told Fox News Digital.
The HRSA director said these new guidelines improve the "safety, quality and consistency of care that's already being delivered across the United States."
Organ donation has changed just within the last decade, according to Lynch. Historically, most donors were declared as "brain dead," meaning they were "legally deceased" at the time the decision was made.
"Now, we're dealing with [DCD], which means that it's an individual who's not brain-dead, but they're very severely injured," he said. "The medical team and the family have come to the decision that they're going to change the goals of care and let that person have a natural, compassionate death."
"In that setting, shortly after they pass away, their organs are removed through a surgical procedure."
The guidelines do not change the roles of the patient’s healthcare team or the organ procurement organization (OPO), the group that coordinates organ donation and recovery. Rather, they set clearer expectations for when donation-related discussions and procedures take place, according to Lynch.
"Historically, it was very, very late in the patient's medical course before there could be a discussion of them being an organ donor," he said. "And that really has two kinds of harm."
One concern was that families may have felt "rushed or pressured" to decide whether to authorize organ donation before they had enough time to make an informed choice.
He said delays could deny patients "the chance to give the gift" of organ donation, as they intended when they signed up to be donors.
TEST YOURSELF WITH OUR LATEST LIFESTYLE QUIZ
The other risk was an "insufficient delivery" of information and recording of decisions, according to Lynch.
He said the new guidelines bring more thorough conversations and clearer records of what information was shared with families, and when.
These conversations are "happening in truly tragic circumstances," Lynch noted, as families and loved ones are feeling fear and grief.
The HRSA aims to ensure that the quality and quantity of communication and medical care is "very high."
"All of this is about elevating this to the level of a medical specialty," he said. "We're making sure through these regulations that there is a level of professionalism and consistency, and that the care people's loved ones are going to get is ... compassionate and respectful."
Dr. Stephanie Widmer, New York City emergency medicine physician and Fox News medical contributor, said families should know that "there are now clearer safeguards," including the five-minute wait and the chance to pause the process.
She added that while organ donation saves lives, protection of the donor "must always come first."
CLICK HERE FOR MORE HEALTH STORIES
"I think these changes are a positive step toward improving patient safety, transparency and public trust," Widmer, who was not involved in the guideline updates, told Fox News Digital. "My concern is whether these safeguards will be consistently enforced across hospitals and organ procurement organizations."
The doctor added that a policy is "only as effective as its implementation," and that additional procedural requirements don’t "unnecessarily interfere with a patient’s wishes to donate."
Widmer said she'd like to see stronger national standards for independent neurological assessments and "greater oversight" of organ procurement practices.
CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR HEALTH NEWSLETTER
"The medical team caring for the patient should remain completely independent of the organ recovery process," she emphasized. "Families also deserve clear explanations of exactly what will happen, including any specialized procedures used to preserve organs."
"The goal should always be to save lives through donation without ever compromising the care, dignity or safety of the donor."
This story was first published by Fox News - Latest. Read the original report
We use cookies to run this site and, with your consent, to measure traffic and improve our content. Necessary cookies are always on. You can accept all cookies or choose which ones to allow. Privacy policy.