We did a Trader Joe's Thanksgiving grocery haul in NYC and a smaller Northwest city. The cheaper one might surprise you.
Thanksgiving is approaching, and Trader Joe's newsletter, Fearless Flyer, has a suggested menu.
Thanksgiving is approaching, and Trader Joe's newsletter, Fearless Flyer, has a suggested menu.
Hoffman/Insider
Grocery stores across the US this weekend will likely be packed with Thanksgiving shoppers.
Affordability is top of mind for many Americans right now, and retailers are leaning into those concerns ahead of the big turkey dinner. Walmart has its $35 Thanksgiving basket that feeds 10 people; Aldi advertised a dinner for 10 for less than $39.
Trader Joe's has gone a different direction to give people more flexibility, instead creating a Thanksgiving shopping guide in its Fearless Flyer — its free seasonal newsletter found online and in stores.
In it, shoppers are guided on which meats to choose, the best stuffing options, different cheeses to assort, and so much more, from wines to desserts. It also pitches some of its holiday items as budget-friendly through playful price callouts — from $2.49 mushroom soup meant to "expand your sense of Trader Joe's value" to $3.79 fried onions intended to avoid "frying your budget."
We wanted to test out what a Thanksgiving dinner grocery receipt looks like at Trader Joe's locations in very different places.
Our New York City-based reporter, Gabbi Shaw, went to one in Manhattan, and our Oregon-based fellow, Tristin Hoffman, went to the only Trader Joe's in her Northwest college town, Eugene. Oregon has no sales tax, while most groceries in NYC are tax-exempt.
Here's what we found, and which shopping trip was cheaper.
Gabbi went to her local Trader Joe's on the Upper East Side of Manhattan.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
Gabbi went on a Tuesday in the mid-morning, and it was still packed. There's really no time to avoid crowds at Trader Joe's.
It's a refurbished New York City Department of Transportation warehouse. It opened in 2021.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
Gabbi said it's easily the most architecturally pleasing Trader Joe's she'd been in — but the lack of easy parking isn't exactly an equal trade-off.
But that's typical of all the Trader Joe's locations in New York City.
There were tons of decorations around the store for fall and Thanksgiving.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
In the aisles, there were also tons of holiday-season products, like advent calendars, peppermint-scented candles, and gingerbread cookies.
The first component of Fearless Flyer's menu Gabbi looked for is also the centerpiece of Thanksgiving: the turkey.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
The organic turkey was slightly pricier than the pre-brined turkey.
The turkey she selected was $33.42 at $2.49 per pound.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
She selected a turkey that weighed about 13.42 pounds.
The turkey was brined in water, sea salt, sugar, natural turkey broth powder, and other natural flavors.
Next up was the other meat, ham. Gabbi chose spiral-sliced uncured ham.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
The Frick's uncured ham wasn't available at this store, but per the Trader Joe's website, it's the same price.
This ham was $52.44 at $6.49 per pound. That's an 8-pound ham.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
It also came with a glaze packet.
A display combined gravy and stuffing. The turkey gravy was $1.69.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
The box contains about 17 ounces of turkey gravy.
A box of cornbread stuffing mix was $4.99.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
The stuffing mix is made with toasted white bread, cornbread croutons, and spices like oregano, sage, onion, and garlic, along with chicken broth and celery.
Fearless Flyer recommended this sweet onion salad kit for $3.99.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
The sweet onion salad kit contains romaine lettuce, kale, radicchio, white cheddar, fried onions, cheese- and garlic-flavored croutons, and comes with a sweet onion vinaigrette.
A jar of cranberry sauce was $3.29.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
The jar contains 12 ounces of cranberry sauce.
There was a large selection of green beans, but I chose the organic ones for $3.49.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
This bag is about one pound.
A 1-pound bag of organic persimmons costs $3.99.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
Gabbi said she could've also chosen single persimmons for 99 cents each.
There was a generous selection of cheeses. Gabbi picked 2.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
She said she's a fan of soft cheese, but a little variety is fun for holidays.
The first selection was a white Stilton cheese with cranberries. Packages were priced from $5 to $8.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
It was priced at $12.99 per pound. Gabbi's selection was on the smaller size, so it was $5.
The second cheese was triple-cream Brie with wild mushrooms, priced from $5 to $7.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
In bulk, this was slightly more expensive at $13.99 per pound. This selection was $5, too.
Nothing pairs better with cheese than wine, though the NYC Trader Joe's locations have limited choices.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
There used to be a designated Trader Joe's wine shop in Union Square, but it closed in 2022. Now, the wine selection is limited to just a couple of small shelves.
Gabbi chose a $6.99 bottle of moscato and a $6.99 bottle of cabernet sauvignon.
For non-drinkers and kids, she selected a bottle of apple cider for $3.49.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
Apple cider is a great alternative to wine or beer.
Last up is dessert. The bakery section at this location was small but mighty.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
There were many types of baked goods to choose from.
The Fearless-Flyer-recommended pumpkin pie cost $6.99.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
This location was out of them, but Gabbi said she could see there had been personal pumpkin pies (or teeny-tiny pumpkin pies in Trader Joe's parlance) priced at $5.49.
The NYC location was out of classic whipped cream, but the topping would've been $2.99.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
All that was left was chocolate whipped cream, which Gabbi said she wasn't really in the mood for, so she left it on the shelf.
My total, after tax, was $143.31.Gabbi Shaw/Business Insider
The receipt would have been $2.99 higher, or $146.30, if the classic whipped cream had been in stock.
Regardless, the haul wasn't too bad — but Gabbi didn't think there were enough sides or desserts to make it a full Thanksgiving meal, especially since she chose turkey and ham.
Also, in New York City, most groceries are tax-exempt, so Gabbi only paid sales tax on the wine and cider, coming out to a whopping $1.55.
But let's see how Eugene compares.
Tristin went to her local Trader Joe's in Eugene, Oregon.Hoffman/Insider
Eugene is a midsize city of about 178,000 and is home to the University of Oregon. There is only one Trader Joe's in town — the next store is nearly an hour's drive away, in Corvallis.
So even though Eugene is so small compared to NYC's 8 million people, Tristin's Friday afternoon shopping trip was quite busy.
The outside displays already featured Christmas garlands and wreaths.Hoffman/Insider
It's never too early to start decorating for Christmas and the holidays, Tristin said.
Inside, the walls and displays were decorated for fall and Thanksgiving.Hoffman/Insider
Tristin said seeing both Thanksgiving and December holiday decorations made this trip even more fun.
Eugene's store offered all-natural, organic, and Glatt Kosher turkeys.Hoffman/Insider
The organic turkey was slightly pricier than the Glatt Kosher turkey. The pre-brined turkey was the cheapest option.
The turkey Tristin selected was $35.03 at $2.49 per pound.Hoffman/Insider
Tristin selected a 14.07-pound all-natural brined young turkey.
The turkey-flavored gravy section was clearly popular. At $1.69, Tristin can see why.Hoffman/Insider
Trader Joe's flaunts its Turkey Gravy as "better than Grandma's!"
The other classic of a Thanksgiving meal is ham. At Eugene's Trader Joe's, a fully cooked spiral ham cost $6.49 per pound.Hoffman/Insider
The ham she chose totaled $54.00.
There was no confusion as to where the stuffing — arguably the best dish at Thanksgiving — was.Hoffman/Insider
Tristin chose the cornbread stuffing mix, which was $4.99.
The apple cabbage slaw salad kit seemed more appealing than the Fearless Flyer's sweet onion salad suggestion.Hoffman/Insider.
Tristin opted for the apple cabbage slaw salad kit, which cost $4.49 —50 cents more than the sweet onion salad.
A small tub of cranberry sauce was $3.99.Hoffman/Insider.
The container holds 16 ounces of cranberry sauce, compared to NYC's 12-ounce jar.
There was only one option for green beans at Eugene's store. One bag cost $2.99 per pound.Hoffman/Insider
The bag, like NYC's, was also one pound.
The bag of persimmons was similarly priced to NYC — at $3.99 per pound.Hoffman/Insider
Each bag contained about three persimmons.
Tristin only likes soft cheese, so she went with her two favorite options.Hoffman/Insider
The triple-cream Brie cheese with wild mushrooms was also priced at $13.99 per pound. Tristin chose one that cost $6.30 total.
The other soft cheese she chose was $14.99 per pound.Hoffman/Insider.
Le Délice de Bourgogne's triple-crème soft-ripened cheese is one of Tristin's favorites. She chose one that cost $6.70 total.
Eugene's Trader Joe's features plenty of local wines from the Willamette Valley, a popular wine region in the US.Hoffman/Insider
Tristin chose King Estate's pinot noir, which cost $24.99.
The non-alcoholic section had plenty of options.Hoffman/Insider
She also selected a $3.49 bottle of sparkling apple cider.
For dessert, Tristin also went with pumpkin pie.Hoffman/Insider
It cost $6.99 total and looked freshly baked.
Every pie needs a topping: whipped cream is the only correct answer.Hoffman/Insider
Tristin chose Dairystar's whipped light cream option, which cost $4.49.
Here's what Tristin's shopping cart looked like at the end of her Thanksgiving grocery run.Hoffman/Insider
The shopping trip took about 20 minutes total.
Tristin's total, with no sales tax, was $164.13.Hoffman/Insider
Oregon's no-sales-tax policy reduced Tristin's total Thanksgiving dinner price, but it was still about $21 more than Gabbi's NYC haul.
Different personal preferences and availability accounted for much of that gap: after setting aside the wine and cheese and adjusting for the different salad kit and meat weights, Tristin's haul was about $4 more.
If Gabbi's preferred whipped cream had been in stock, the two hauls would have been virtually tied — with NYC still about $1.40 cheaper.
Read the original article on Business InsiderThis story was first published by Business Insider. Read the original report
We use cookies to run this site and, with your consent, to measure traffic and improve our content. Necessary cookies are always on. You can accept all cookies or choose which ones to allow. Privacy policy.